| Issue date: May 16, 1999
Investing with
a conscience
How to make money without compromising your principles
nvestors
who want to be socially responsible often have made a trade-off:
a clean conscience vs. good performance. Steer clear of mutual funds
investing in alcohol, tobacco, weapons or nuclear power - pick only
funds that adhere to a strict social agenda - and you'd likely lose
money. Not anymore.
Today there are some 200 mutual funds in the socially responsible
investing world, says analyst Stephanie Kendall at Wiesenberger,
a Rockville, Md., research firm. That includes "green funds" and
funds that screen according to religious or moral principles (for
instance, opposition to abortion). On average, they perform on par
with funds overall, with a few far outperforming funds overall.
Socially screened large-cap growth and growth-and-income funds (combined)
averaged a 20.69% return over the past three years, vs. unscreened
funds' 19.83%.
What you
need to know:
How these funds work. They start out like traditional funds,
by picking companies for financial reasons. Then they apply a second
screen, to weed out companies that do something they find unacceptable,
such as manufacturing guns or excluding gay partners from health
benefits. There are also socially responsible index funds, notably
the Domini Social Equity fund and the Citizens Index fund, both
of which have received the top rating from Morningstar. These screen
the S&P 500 to weed out unacceptable companies, then add back
acceptable companies.
Top domestic
stock funds that screen for social issues
FUND
(Category)
|
RETURN
1-yr. |
(%)
3-yr.* |
Noah Fund
(Growth) |
50.75 |
- |
IPS Millennium Fund
(Growth and income)
|
45.54 |
34.49 |
USAA First Start
(Growth)
|
31.89 |
- |
Citizens Index Fund
(Growth)
|
30.39 |
35.47 |
American Trust Allegiance
(Growth)
|
30.35 |
- |
S&P 500
(for reference)
|
18.47 |
28.08 |
*Note: Some funds are too new to have three-year returns.
What they invest in - Noah: screens out companies with business
in pornography, abortion, alcohol, gambling and alternative lifestyles.
IPS Millennium: focus on animal rights. USAA First Start: traditional
social investing. Citizens Index: screens for alcohol, tobacco,
gambling, weapons, nuclear power, etc. American Trust Allegiance:
Christian Scientist fund that avoids medical firms.
Advantages? "Say you're interested in the environment.
Whether you buy a company that believes in recycling or practicing
energy efficiency, you'll see that positively impact the bottom
line in the long run," says Citizens Funds VP Joe Keefe. "The same
is true of companies that invest in their own workforce by allowing
flex time or other opportunities." Many people believe companies
conscious of avoiding labor or environmental problems are less likely
to be a target of lawsuits.
How to pick one. Figure out what matters to you in terms
of social qualifications as well as investment objective and performance
- then find the fund that fits best. To see what sort of screens
a fund applies, visit www.socialinvest.org.
Source: Wiesenberger
|